The shelf

The Three Lives of Thomasina (1963) poster

All Ages

The Three Lives of Thomasina

1963

In a Scottish village in 1912, veterinarian Andrew MacDhui is a widower who has lost his faith. When he puts down his daughter Mary's beloved cat, Thomasina, the heartbroken girl turns away from him, and a reclusive woman the village calls a witch may hold the key.

The default: films the whole family can watch together; any scary or intense moments for the littlest viewers are flagged in the Context Notes.

Runtime
1 hour 37 minutes
Rating
NR
Director
Don Chaffey
Cast
Patrick McGoohan, Susan Hampshire, Karen Dotrice, Laurence Naismith, and Jean Anderson
Picture
Color
Genre
Fantasy, Drama, Thriller, Mystery, Family
Shelf
Family

Why it’s here

A proud father's heart is broken and healed, and faith and love are restored.

Context notes

For parents, before you press play.

Thomasina's apparent death and Mary's grief, including her refusal to speak to her father, are sad; the film shows the estrangement healed through repentance. Children who have lost a pet may be upset that this cat comes back.

Discussion questions

When the credits end, go around the room. Each person gives the film a score out of ten and says why.

  1. Why was Mary so angry with her father?
  2. What did Andrew learn from Lori?
  3. Was Lori a witch? Why did people think so?
  4. How did Andrew and Mary forgive each other?

Content advisory

Common Sense Media 8+: the death of a pet, who comes back; a grieving child.

Trailer

Best edition

The disc comes first.

The Three Lives of Thomasina (1964)

DVD · July 6, 2004

Coming later

Where to stream

Streaming services are not listed yet. When they are, this note stays secondary to the disc.

IMDb (opens in a new tab) · Letterboxd (opens in a new tab)